|
AN
IMMIGRANT HISTORY OF AMERICAN WAR RESISTERS IN CANADA
As this documentary reveals, Americans who came to Canada in the
1960s to avoid fighting in the Vietnam War were not the first American
draft evaders to settle in this country. In Dr. Nevitt's case, the
concept of dodging the draft was very much alive during the American
Civil War of the 1860s. In fact, there is a place in New Brunswick
- in the Mapleton District of Carleton county - referred to as Skedaddle
Ridge. It was a place where many Americans settled after "skedaddling"
across the border from Maine to escape having to fight in the war.
While many immigrants have fled to Canada to avoid fighting against
a particular enemy, many others have come as conscientious objectors,
or pacifists. Religious members of the Society of Friends - Quakers
- have consistently resisted fighting in wars. Starting with the American
Revolutionary War in 1776, Quakers began escaping to Canada to avoid
be the violence of battle. Back home, their fellow Americans called
them cowards, and worse. Many Quakers were accused of treason because
they would not fight against the English. Sometimes they were imprisoned,
tortured, or publically humiliated. For the Quakers, and many other
religious groups like them, Canada provided sanctuary and guaranteed
them the right not to bear arms.
At about the same time the Quakers first began emigrating to Canada,
crowds of United Empire Loyalists were arriving. Unlike the Quakers,
they didn't necessarily object to war but chose to remain loyal to
the British King who was at war with the American colonies. Vilified
by other Americans, they were often imprisoned, tortured and their
lands confiscated. They fled to Canada not only for the cause of the
British Crown, but for the promise of free land. The British were
in a hurry to populate their northern lands and encouraged Black and
white Americans to settle. Loyalist communities continued for over
two centuries in Nova Scotia, Picton County Ontario, and southern
Ontario.
For the next hundred years, Americans, and people who lived in what
is now called Canada, easily crossed each other's borders, often to
find work, visit family or to settle. But that all changed with the
American Civil War. President Abraham Lincoln became desperate for
soldiers to fight against the South. Despite offering money for soldiers
to sign up, the government had to enacted legislation to forcibly
draft men into the army in 1862. There was also a provision allowing
citizens to appoint a substitute in their place. This was one of the
reasons so many Canadians decided to sign up for the war, and there
was a brisk trade in soldiers of fortune in border cities such as
Buffalo and Detroit.
But some of the American draftees decided to put themselves out of
reach of authorities by crossing into Canada. These men were called
"skedaddlers." Desertion and draft dodging were especially
prevalent in border states such as Maine, New Hampshire, New York,
Wisconsin and Minnesota. When the war ended, many draft dodgers decided
to return home to America. Luckily, an amnesty was proclaimed in May
of 1865, assuring them that they wouldn't be punished. Even people
who had left the U.S. for Canada before the war caught the spirit
of the time and moved back to the country where they'd been born.
Ironically, fifty years later, it was the U.S. that provided sanctuary
for Canadians who didn't want to enlist during the First World War.
When the Americans joined the fight overseas in 1917, Canadian draft
dodgers lost their refuge.
The next big wave of draft dodgers, or war "resisters" as
they prefer to be known, started arriving in Canada in the 1960s,
when the controversy around the Vietnam War drove almost 60,000 Americans
to Canada. Some came out of conscience, some out of fear. One historian
called their presence "...the largest politically motivated migration
from the United States since the United Empire Loyalists moved north
to oppose the American Revolution." In the case of the war resisters,
it was a clear case of voting with one's feet on the policies of one's
country. Today, with amnesties allowing virtually all to return and
with the fervor of the time long extinguished, about half remain,
fitting comfortably into Canada's culture. Although some estimates
are significantly higher, census data suggest that almost 60,000 Americans
took up residence in Canada during the Vietnam War - just about the
same number as those who died in Vietnam. They included draft dodgers
and "deserters, and surprisingly, about half of the 60,000 who
moved north were women. Canada was attractive to draft dodgers and
deserters because it was easily reached, had no extradition treaty,
and had a tradition of welcoming Americans who felt unwelcome in the
United States. On January 21, 1977, President Jimmy Carter issued
an amnesty for draft dodgers. Later amnesties covered deserters.
Top of page.
|