OBSTACLES
Like Kit Coleman, most 19th
century Irish immigrants who came to Canada had a strong desire to improve
their material conditions. Kit, as the sole support of two children,
(in a world without daycares or social assistance!) was facing a plight
that has plagued single mothers throughout history. She, like many other
women, took a series of low-paying jobs at first. And like many mothers
today, she tried working at home, writing magazine articles between
household chores. Though Kit was urban and eventually used her writing
skills and concern about social issues to hurl herself into the world
of newspapers, she had the same grit and determination as many rural
immigrants who were looking for better land and advantages that eluded
them at home. These rural poor moved from a system in Ireland where
land was scarce and labour was plentiful to one where labour was scarce
and land was plentiful. Canada! The price was a greater degree of isolation
than rural life offered in Ireland, but it was one that most were willing
to pay.
The Irish experience in 19th century Canada was very different from
that of 20th century ethnic minorities. In many ways, a familiarity
with Britain helped the Irish settle here. In contrast to many recent
immigrant groups, the Irish spoke English, were familiar with British
political, social and cultural traditions, and formed a substantial
proportion of the population. As we know, Kit Coleman struggled when
she arrived in Canada, yet her ability to speak the language (and use
it so well!), allowed her to move fairly quickly from the margins of
society. Compared to ethnic groups from India and the Pacific Rim, the
Irish like Kit followed a faster road to the Canadian mainstream; indeed,
they played a significant role in shaping the mainstream.
However, rabid anti-Irish sentiments were hurled at the immigrants in
19th Century Canada, and many Irish Protestants looked down on Irish
Catholics (and vise versa) as inferior beings. Irish Protestants had
a social advantage in the early years of settlement, sharing an affinity
with the predominant Church of England. Irish Catholics were feared
and ostracized for decades by Canadians haunted by images of Famine
Irish limping off fever ships, contaminated by disease and poverty.
Nasty clashes and riots between Irish Protestants and Catholics continued
in major Canadian cities until the turn of the 20th century. And the
Irish themselves - both Protestant and Catholic - were as capable as
other white ethnic groups in Canada of harbouring racial prejudice and
of attempting to keep non-white immigrants out of the country. 6
Unlike some 20th century immigrants who came to Canada with a view to
making money and returning home, the 19th century Irish generally stayed
in North America, although large numbers who arrived in Canada went
on to the United States. Interestingly, it appears that Irish immigration
to Canada contained a much higher proportion of women that that in more
recent ethnic groups. 7
From the early 1830s, a significant majority of the Irish in Canada
settled in Ontario, like Kit. Shortly after Confederation, two thirds
of Irish Canadians lived in the province. Quebec, was a far second and
New Brunswick a close third. 8
Endnotes
1 - 18 Wilson, David, The Irish in Canada, Canada's Ethnic
Groups, Canadian Historical Society, 1989
The Canadian Encyclopedia 2000 McClelland and Stewart
Top
of page.